top of page

Gaming and Mental Health: How to Read the Claims

Mar 5, 2025
3 min read

Updated: Oct 7

A headline says a game can reduce anxiety, build confidence, or improve mental health. You enjoy games, so the possibility sounds appealing. But what does that claim actually tell you about whether the game will help you?


It helps to separate a few different ideas: enjoying an activity, using it as a coping tool, bringing it into therapy, and testing it as a treatment. Those experiences can overlap, but evidence for one doesn't automatically establish the others.


Ask what was actually studied


“Gaming improves mental health” is much broader than most individual studies can show. Look for the details behind the headline:


  • Which game or type of play was involved?

  • Who participated, and what were they experiencing?

  • Was the game used independently or with professional support?

  • What changed: enjoyment, stress, symptoms, or daily functioning?

  • How long were participants followed?


A finding about one game, age group, or setting may not apply to your circumstances. A study that asks people how they feel after playing also answers a different question from a study comparing a clinical treatment with another treatment.


Look for a comparison


People's symptoms and circumstances can change for many reasons. If participants feel better after using a game, it matters whether they improved more than people in a comparison group.


For example, a randomized study of the commercial game Journey did not find the expected depression-prevention advantage over its comparison groups. A separate 2024 study using game-console lotteries in Japan found well-being benefits in that setting. It was not a clinical trial showing that all games treat depression or anxiety.


These findings don't cancel each other out. They examined different questions. A careful claim names what the evidence supports and leaves room for what remains uncertain.


Notice when the wording gets ahead of the evidence


Be cautious about promises of permanent change, automatic skill transfer, or a game “rewiring” your brain in a particular helpful way. An explanation can sound scientific without having been demonstrated.


A testimonial is also different from research. Someone can genuinely enjoy or benefit from an experience without that story predicting your result. If an article describes a client success story, it should be clear whether it is an actual, appropriately shared account or an imagined illustration.


You don't need to become a researcher to ask a useful question: “What supports that claim, and how closely does it match what you're recommending to me?”


Your own experience still matters


You don't need a clinical study's permission to enjoy a hobby. Playing with a friend, exploring a story, or spending time on a satisfying puzzle may be meaningful to you.


Notice what happens in your actual life. Does play give you a welcome break? Do you feel connected to people you like? Do you feel more frustrated afterward? Are sleep, spending or other commitments being affected?


An activity can be helpful in one context and unhelpful in another. You can change the game, the time you play, the people you play with, or whether you play at all. Benefits don't have to be dramatic to be worth noticing.


Bring specific questions to therapy


If a therapist suggests a game, ask how it connects with your goals, what alternatives are available, and how you will review its usefulness. The game should not become a test you have to pass or an activity you must enjoy.


At Tall Grass Therapy, I am a Certified Geek Therapist. Games, stories and roleplay are optional ways to explore what matters to you. You can learn about my geek-informed approach and ask how it might fit your concerns.


I offer online therapy for adults in Florida and Oregon. I'm maintaining a waitlist for new therapy clients. Join the waitlist through Paubox.

 
 
bottom of page